Qui-Gon vs Starkiller (sabers only)

Sabers only.

Round 1: TFU Starkiller as of his fight with Vader
Round 2: TFU2 Starkiller as of his fight with Vader.

If Augmentation is allowed then SK both rounds.

Edit: Actually unsure honestly.

Qui-Gon dies. Both rounds.

Grey ragdolling

SK destroys

Starkiller wins.

Can we get some reasons up in here?

Starkiller, both rounds. More nimble, more reserves, and greater technical variety. The 2nd blade in the second round makes it even easier for Starkiller

SK both rounds :
jinn can´t withstand this kind of raw power even though he might be technically more skilled with the blade (academically speaking)
it is not enough to overcome such an opponent . SK has more reserves , he is stronger and has better "stamina" .
this would look much like jinns fight with TPM maul , jinn would burn out his reserves , get tired and make some mistake eventually .

You think Starkiller has a chance against TPM Maul? You're dreaming buddy.

Meatpants wrote:You think Starkiller has a chance against TPM Maul? You're dreaming buddy.

yes he would have a chance . reasons why he shouldn´t ?!

SK would lose pure sabers confrontation but he would take the force round .
all out battle could go either way but probably SK .

after all you created this thread so why doing it if you believe SK has "no chance" against TPM maul :
given jinns rather good performance against maul it would imply you already have your own answer .
(or maybe you are just trolling with your previous post)

Umm.... 

Anyway, you think Starkiller would lose to Maul in sabers, but would beat Jinn. So you must think Starkiller is close to Maul in sabers?

starkiller doesn´t have to be technically more skilled per say .
just like anakin is not more technically skilled than dooku .
it is a matter of power . starkiller would overpower jinn in a duel .
jinn would need to burn his reserves just to parry SKs blows and to keep up with him .


anyway you did not provide any response yourself .
so either answer or stop trolling or whatever it is you are trying to do here .

Meatpants wrote:You think Starkiller has a chance against TPM Maul? You're dreaming buddy.

Why? What directly places Maul above Galen?

lol for real. by the time of tfu vader is best fighter in the galaxy, above both yoda and sheev man. he should be better than TPM lol

Scaling favors Jinn.

how? jinn< TPM maul< TCW maul< TCW sheev. 

vader has quotes to puts him above sheev in dueling, and SK was doing pretty well against him

Suited vader is not a tier 9 duelist lmao. He's at best a tier 8 but more likely a tier 7 based on his duel with Ben Kenobi

u got something to back that up?

How about him nearly stalemating a ben Kenobi whose saber skills have atrophied for the past 20 years.

Galen slaps. While Jinn is obviously technically better, Galen is tiers above as a Force User, and the augmentation disparity is far too large for Jinn's skill advantage to ever compensate.

Jinn might be better in technical skill, but Galen will press Jinn hard enough to deplete him of his Force reserves thanks to his much greater power.

Vader's a tier 8, not a tier 9. His Force powers make him a solid 8.

Jinn is better in skill, but SK has better reserves, stamina, and is a lot more unorthodox. He wins.