Vader (KF) vs RotJ Sidious

Stipulation: Sidious kills Padme in front of Vader

Who wins?

anakin loses, imo. unless he uses the "reality changing" will fuckery thingy

Lol, Anakin loses. Mustafar was = ROTS Sidious, and ROTJ Sidious is decently more powerful than him. Unless Anakin goes full ham and taps into his full potential again, he loses.

Annie dies badly

Anakin in that mindset is easy pickings for Sidious.

Jacen wrote:Stipulation: Sidious kills Padme in front of Vader

Who wins?

That emotional trigger could either way - KF Vader could stomp or get stomped (though without the trigger he would get stomped anyway).