AOTC Obi Wan vs Rahm Kota

Sabers only
All out

Kenobi easily.

Kenobi stomps

Love to know why this incarnation of Kenobi is "stomping".
Who has AOTC Kenobi ever stomped?

Kenobi edges.

Kenobi has far better feats, he pressured Dooku a bit, while Kota was ragdolled by an opponent in the same tier as Dooku in force power.

AOTC Kenobi has better feats than being ragdolled by TFU Vader.

^^^

Kenobi

mastercilghal wrote:Kenobi has far better feats, he pressured Dooku a bit, while Kota was ragdolled by an opponent in the same tier as Dooku in force power.

Dooku was capable of ragdolling Kenobi though....

Kota contending with early game Marek should be enough to put him above AOTC Kenobi

Meatpants wrote:

mastercilghal wrote:Kenobi has far better feats, he pressured Dooku a bit, while Kota was ragdolled by an opponent in the same tier as Dooku in force power.

Dooku was capable of ragdolling Kenobi though....

Not really, Kenobi simply didn’t have the time to mount a force shield. It was noted in the junior novel. In fact, Obi wan pressured Dooku a bit in the AOTC novelization, while exhausted.

He was talking about AoTC Kenobi

Kenobi would win, but I question it being an outright stomp.

@mastercilghal

Not really, Kenobi simply didn’t have the time to mount a force shield. It was noted in the junior novel. In fact, Obi wan pressured Dooku a bit in the AOTC novelization, while exhausted.

The fact that Kenobi couldn't raise a Force Shield in time is completely irrelevant. If Dooku is so fast and so skilled that he can simply TK stomp Kenobi while engaging Anakin then he will do so in every hypothetical matchup between the two making any arguments that Kenobi can compete with Dooku bunk. AOTC doesn't contradict this. Kenobi after summoning all of his strength only manages to briefly put Dooku on the back foot while the latter was toying with him. That said though I agree that Kenobi still wins this.

AotC Kenobi drove back a caught offguard Dooku who had been toying with him the whole time.

According to the script Dooku increased the tempo of his attack(which proves he wasn't going all out eariler) and Kenobi is pushed to the limits to defend himself:

Spoiler:

Going by the novelization Dooku wasn't worried until Anakin showcases his speed, further proof Kenobi driving Dooku back wasn't a big deal:

Spoiler:

If that wasn't enough the same novel reveals Dooku reserved his best performance for Yoda.

Spoiler:

^