★ Top Fifteen Tournament #5 - Anakin Skywalker / Darth Krayt

"Peak Vader" is a cripple

Knightfall Vader was stronger imo, and in George Lucas'

I attribute Mustafar Vader's loss to Obi-Wan to his recklessness, and the fact that Obi-Wan knew Anakin well enough to counter him.

There may have been other factors, like the fact that Knightfall Vader hadn't gotten sleep and the fact that Soresu provides optimal defense against a reckless battling style and punishes it by taking precise strikes when the opportunity presents itself.

I don't mind Krayt being ranked Knightfall Vader-tier, though.

BoD: "KFV isn’t > Yoda, lol. Peak Vader, Sidious and Yoda are all at the same point. Yoda matched Sheev, and Anakin = Sheev. Yoda also has the advantage of skill, knowledge and experience."

I thought you meant suit Vader by peak Vader. Just realized you're saying all three of them were equal by RotS.

Why did you bump this

Just wanted to share my thoughts on a comment, but it turned out my thoughts were ineffectual.