Favorite Star Wars movie under Disney so far?

I know a lot of people are underwhelmed with how Disney is handling Star Wars so far, but out of the four films that have come out, which one do you like the best?
For me it's probably Rogue One or Force Awakens.

Rouge One is my 3rd favorite of all time.

TLJ is probably my 5th

TFA is trash, TLJ is trash and Solo is trash. R1 is mediocre but it's overall the best.

RO, aka the only good one.

Rogue One, it’s pretty good

TFA was a decent pass time, nothing great or bad. More like one of the forgettable JJ Star Trek movies than a Star Wars movie-going experience. Haven't really had much incentive the watch the rest of the ST. Haven't seen the movie but the RO novelization was a disappointment, especially considering how good it's tie-in novel Catalyst was.

They are all equally bad

R1 was nice. However TFA was quite meh and TLJ being straight trash. Solo was just unnecessary. Who the fuck cares about Chewie and Han taking a shower together? What's next, Han was a furry and gave Chewbacca blowjob? (Don't get any ideas J.K.R.)

HellfireUnit wrote:R1 was nice. However TFA was quite meh and TLJ being straight trash. Solo was just unnecessary. Who the fuck cares about Chewie and Han taking a shower together? What's next, Han was a furry and gave Chewbacca blowjob? (Don't get any ideas J.K.R.)

For anyone who thinks TFA is meh I am willing to do a formal debate on why it's complete trash once my current SSs are done.

NotAA3 wrote:For anyone who thinks TFA is meh I am willing to do a formal debate on why it's complete trash once my current SSs are done.

I used to think it was trash but after TLJ I realized it isn't tbh. It is just bad.

They are all putrid dog piss, but maybe Solo.

1.Rogue One, would've been a genuinely great film without the entirely redundant Galen death scene in it.
2.TFA, Adam Driver saves this movie and his scene with Ford is brutal.
3.TLJ, the only good scene is Yoda and the rest is atrocious. Instead of Adam Driving the movie, we get this completely out of place Star Wars: Casino Royale sub-plot that not even Del Toro could save.
4.Solo, has a completely random ass cast in roles they are far bigger than and it's frankly boring.

I'm probably alone in saying Solo is the best out of the new ones so far. Some parts of TLJ had a lot of potential, but didn't quite tap it well enough to be worthwhile (for example Yoda, Luke being a badass at the end). The only thing I liked about R1 were the Vader scenes. TFA was just completely unlikeable for me personally.

Solo wasn't really bad, it was OK actually. However it was completely pointless and unnecessary addition to Canon. Besides that, even though Alden did his best, noone is capable of replacing Ford. I am unsure how to feel about Beckett and Vos but Lando was awful. If I had to rank Disney movies it'd be like R1>>>Solo>>TFA>TLJ.

This rouge one disrespect fuck you all. 

The nostalgia factor has it above Rots for me you cretins

Flunky Cyborg wrote:This rouge one disrespect fuck you all. 

The nostalgia factor has it above Rots for me you cretins

The characters in Rogue One were barely memorable though. I still agree it's a good movie, and Krennic has to be one of the best and most underrated Star Wars villains

LadyKulvax wrote:1.Rogue One, would've been a genuinely great film without the entirely redundant Galen death scene in it.
2.TFA, Adam Driver saves this movie and his scene with Ford is brutal.
3.TLJ, the only good scene is Yoda and the rest is atrocious. Instead of Adam Driving the movie, we get this completely out of place Star Wars: Casino Royale sub-plot that not even Del Toro could save.
4.Solo, has a completely random ass cast in roles they are far bigger than and it's frankly boring.

Yoda scene was so out of place, and the summoning thunder thing he did with the force was dumb as hell.

LadyKulvax wrote:1.Rogue One, would've been a genuinely great film without the entirely redundant Galen death scene in it.
2.TFA, Adam Driver saves this movie and his scene with Ford is brutal.
3.TLJ, the only good scene is Yoda and the rest is atrocious. Instead of Adam Driving the movie, we get this completely out of place Star Wars: Casino Royale sub-plot that not even Del Toro could save.
4.Solo, has a completely random ass cast in roles they are far bigger than and it's frankly boring.

Yoda scene was so out of place, and the summoning thunder thing he did with the force was dumb as hell.

Yoda scene was bullshit. If you can interact with the physical world and summon storms, go and oneshot that sons of gun Kylo and Snoke.

I mean I think that the idea is they are part of the force now. They can't interfere with the future, they aren't gods, they understand the force in its entirety so why would they kill kylo and snoke? Empires rise and empires fall the light wins some the dark others.

However it still appears that Yoda favors Light over Dark Side. His comment about Rey implies that clearly. They are not Gods, yeah so why in the hell Force Spirits are allowed to interact with the physical world? If Yoda can summon lightning and destroy things, he should do it considering he didn't show any belief towards the balance.

Also Dark Side is considered to be unnatural and its absence means balance. So why not smite the adversaries?

Haven't seen Solo, but out of the others Rogue One is definitely my favorite. An entertaining movie with a consistent tone that does the least damage to the Star Wars continuity.

People will probably crucify me for this but my favorite is TLJ. I think most of them are pretty decent though RO and Solo are pretty unneeded they were still fun. TLJ is probably my #2 of all time.