Re: Underrated/overrated characters on forums?

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

I mean...he’s likely on the same level as ROTS Wankatine, maybe Yoda’s equal

I really don't see how. Approaching them maybe, but he was comparable (maybe slightly superior) to post boost Sheev, who then underwent over 10 years of power growth on top of that.

[AncientPowerSuspect Hero | Level Four]

How dare you insult Kun the omnipotent, who scales above Vitiate!

Haven't you heard? Exar scales above DE Sidious too! While weakened!

Literally no one says kriff like this about Exar.

The fact you two have to go around strawmanning Kun because you lost arguments against him is pretty pathetic.

BoD, you specifically tried to claim Vitiate has canonical superiority over Kun but were debunked when you realised the SWTOR:E is an entirely IU source. Just accept that and move on. Come up with a feats comparison that proves it instead of going around mocking Kun supporters when they're not around. This is sad.

[EmperorCaedusLevel Three]

Kun > Malak > Revan KOTOR > Revan Reborn > Novel Vitiate >>> SWTOR Vitiate

Is it useless to resist.

[The Witness]

Kotor Revan>Malak

[EmperorCaedusLevel Three]

Everything should be <

[The Witness]

I see now

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

BoD, you specifically tried to claim Vitiate has canonical superiority over Kun but were debunked when you realised the SWTOR:E is an entirely IU source. Just accept that and move on. Come up with a feats comparison that proves it instead of going around mocking Kun supporters when they're not around. This is sad.

Lmao. Nothing about that was debunked. I gave up trying to convince you when you continued to use sources like Kun being the most powerful at a time when Vitiate was explicitly an unknown entity (and before Vitiate's status as the most powerful Sith of his time was established). Your argument was that because he's mentioned in a vague holonet entry, then obviously Kun > Vitiate based on that quote, which is frankly bollocks. There's also the codex, which combines IU and OOU knowledge, making it a perfectly credible source.

[caffeineandshiny]

How dare you insult Kun the omnipotent, who scales above Vitiate!

Haven't you heard? Exar scales above DE Sidious too! While weakened!

Literally no one says kriff like this about Exar.

The fact you two have to go around strawmanning Kun because you lost arguments against him is pretty pathetic.

BoD, you specifically tried to claim Vitiate has canonical superiority over Kun but were debunked when you realised the SWTOR:E is an entirely IU source. Just accept that and move on. Come up with a feats comparison that proves it instead of going around mocking Kun supporters when they're not around. This is sad.

When have I lost an argument against Kun? My last post on the matter specifically started with "regardless (this is the part where I try to get back on topic)". Aka, it was going off the original topic and running in circles for far too long and I was attempting to "get back on topic". I also posted it before your final response; continuing the conversation was pointless, nothing anyone says is ever going to change your mind (which is fine, you are entitled to your opinion and I have agreed with certain things you have said in the past, not the least of which being your defense of Tulak Hord). You were using a scaling chain that was flawed at every point along it (not even just a single link) and threw up a shield of "maybes" and a German blurb to justify ignoring how the fights went. I felt like plenty of people could see the problems in it without me having to have the last word.

And its obviously a joke, and not even one directed at you.

The whole point of this topic is to bring up wank characters and underrated characters. Of COURSE there are going to be jokes and over exaggerations about how high a character is ranked. And when it comes to Kun statements like that aren't so far off the truth from what has been said in the past.

The people who overused the author opinion that Exar > Sidious a few years ago most certainly WERE trying to argue that and it most certainly is LoL worthy.

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/exar-kun-vs-darth-sidious-1762083/

[The lord of hungerLevel Two]

Underrated characters ironically speaking are exar kun,vader,malak,bane,ulic quel droma and jaina solo 


Overated characters: nyax,plagueis,Cáedus,valkorion,nihilus and dooku

[NevesYtneves (DC77)Level Seven]

Underrated characters ironically speaking are exar kun,vader,malak,bane,ulic quel droma and jaina solo 


Overated characters: nyax,plagueis,Cáedus,valkorion,nihilus and dooku

Lol.

[The lord of hungerLevel Two]

Underrated characters ironically speaking are exar kun,vader,malak,bane,ulic quel droma and jaina solo 


Overated characters: nyax,plagueis,Cáedus,valkorion,nihilus and dooku

Lol.

i mean in other forums he is extremely overrated,the most brilliant example of that is comic vine and whowouldwin

[NevesYtneves (DC77)Level Seven]

Here most people have him pretty low tbh.

[The lord of hungerLevel Two]

Here most people have him pretty low tbh.

lol at least its not like vader where some people think its on the same level as aotc anakin

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

Underrated: Caedus, Cade, Meetra Surik, Bane, Maul, AOTC/TCW Mace, Kyp Durron, novel Vitiate, Ezra Bridger.

Underrated but gaining respect: Malgus, Vader, Kanan Jarrus.

Bit underrated: ROTS Mace, unchained Vaylin, Satele Shan.

Rated about right: KFV, Yoda, Sidious (ROTS - DE), TPM Mace, Valkorion, Outlander, Mara-Jade Skywalker, Arcann, Ahsoka Tano.

Bit overrated: Obi-Wan Kenobi, Count Dooku, Vitiate, SoR Revan, GM Luke, Darish Vol, Darth Marr, Cal Kestis.

Overrated: ESB/ROTJ Luke, TPM/pre-TPM Sidious, Revan Reborn, prime Krayt, Mustafar Kenobi.

[lorenzo.r.2ndLevel Three]

i think Yoda, KFV, and ROTS seem slightly overrated to me as well, but i think it depends too, cuz its on certain circumstances that i see the 'wank'. oh man TPM sheev is super wank mode activated 100%. i think mustafar Kenobi can be a bit overrated as well. i think valk can be overrated, the same way as ROTS sheev. i think DE sheev is also overrated. vitiate is also a bit overrated imo. ugh revan can be hella overrated at times. ROTJ luke too. i think krayt can be underrated tbh. caedus also seems to be underrated.  Vader is EASILY the most underrated character here.

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

i think Yoda, KFV, and ROTS seem slightly overrated to me as well, but i think it depends too, cuz its on certain circumstances that i see the 'wank'. oh man TPM sheev is super wank mode activated 100%. i think mustafar Kenobi can be a bit overrated as well. i think valk can be overrated, the same way as ROTS sheev. i think DE sheev is also overrated. vitiate is also a bit overrated imo. ugh revan can be hella overrated at times. ROTJ luke too. i think krayt can be underrated tbh. caedus also seems to be underrated.  Vader is EASILY the most underrated character here.

Valk definitely isn't overrated. His feats are among the best in the mythos for a Force user, and he scales pretty massively above Vaylin and the Outlander.

[lorenzo.r.2ndLevel Three]

i think he is tbh. people still put him above ROTS sheev, for some reason, and say that he is about as strong as DE sheev or some such. i highly disagree with this.

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

Because his feats blow almost all of ROTS Sheev's out of the water, not to mention his ridiculous scaling.

[lorenzo.r.2ndLevel Three]

he can have all the scaling and feats he wants. iirc, Obi Wan has some TK feats that are better than sheev's. him being above AOTC anakin, who has some of the best TK feats in the series is low key better than almost all of Sheev's TK feats, even though Sheev>>>>>>> AOTC anakin. I go by statements and accolades, and some of them make me think sheev > Valk

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

he can have all the scaling and feats he wants. iirc, Obi Wan has some TK feats that are better than sheev's.

Like?

him being above AOTC anakin, who has some of the best TK feats in the series is low key better than almost all of Sheev's TK feats, even though Sheev>>>>>>> AOTC anakin. I go by statements and accolades,

AOTC Anakin has statements indicating he's the most powerful Jedi of his time even at that point, yet I doubt you have him > Yoda.

and some of them make me think sheev > Valk

Valk has similar accolades and also the feats to back it up.

[O-Siri]

Dooku is ridiculously overrated. Somehow being exhausted by AotC Anakin(words of Dooku fans not me) and only defending yourself against Yoda while being severely outclassed in all relevant sources puts you above TPM Sidious and Maul in his stomping range.

End-of-RotS Kenobi. People act like he bumped up an entire class or something when all he did was dig deeper than he had before. He isn't beating Dooku or holding his own against Sidious. 

Ben likewise. Ridiculous claims of him being "only slightly less powerful"l than "end-of-rots" Kenobi. No, the guy is a done retired old man who can't keep pace with an overly cautious Vader in a low-intensity tactical duel and in his own words is "too old for this sort of thing". Too old to take a trip Alderaan? And this guy is supposed to be better than "IH Kenobi"? Seriously?

Anakin. The guy is not Sidious level. It's debatable if he's even better than Mace. Fact fighting is 90% mental and he isn't mentally above Kenobi, and not just specific to Mustafar. The "hindered" argument is old outdated fanfiction. He's physically gifted but mentally weak, that's why he turned to the dark side. It puts him a cut below Yoda and Sidious and debatably Mace too. Kenobi wasn't "amped" he dug deep and fought against his own reluctance to kill his brother. Why Anakin a dark sider trying to kill Obi-Wan would be more hindered than Obi-Wan a light sider who explicitly doesn't want to kill Anakin is beyond me.

[lorenzo.r.2ndLevel Three]

like pushing huge ass trees down and bending Grievous' metallic whatever like it was a cheap spoon, which Sheev can obviously replicate, but has never done so.


i would like to see one of those tbh. of course i dont. i dont even have prime anakin above yoda either, so yeah.


i never disagreed with that. i just think that Sidious accolades put him above valk by ROTS. As in, very very close, but never above.

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

like pushing huge ass trees down

This really isn't that impressive for a mid to high tier like Sheev, Mace or even Kenobi.

and bending Grievous' metallic whatever like it was a cheap spoon, which Sheev can obviously replicate, but has never done so.

No, but he effortlessly dominated Grievous' mind in Labyrinth of Evil. This is hardly a feat beyond Sheev when Sheev has feats like effortlessly ragdolling TCW Maul, who was ~ pre-ROTS Obi-Wan and would give even IH Kenobi a good to great fight.

i would like to see one of those tbh. of course i dont. i dont even have prime anakin above yoda either, so yeah.

Will have to find them again but they're floating around the board.

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

[lorenzo.r.2ndLevel Three]

i awalys took those "powerful in the force" statements with a grain of salt, since it can mean both power and potential ,but they never karking specify lol

[Sponsored content]