Prime Darth Malgus VS Prime Satele Shan

It is an old topic, but I am interested in your opinion who would be superior if they had another encounter while being in their best conditions. In my opinion Malgus actually won in both two duels they had before.

Satele gets her ass beaten a third time

Satele holding off Valk for as long as she did is better than anything Malgus has or ever will do.

Satele Shan's skills with a Lightsaber might not be at par with Darth Malgus but she is really powerful in the ways of the Force - she flattened a location on Odessen and she could Fold Space as well (she will demonstrate this skill to The Alliance Commander depending upon dialogue options, leaving the player red faced). She was also able to slow down Tenebrae's effort of hollow her out - unprecedented demonstration of mental durability and willpower. She is LEGIT powerhouse from any perspective and can more than hold her own against any opponent by now.

S_W_LeGenD wrote:Satele Shan's skills with a Lightsaber might not be at par with Darth Malgus but she is really powerful in the ways of the Force - she flattened a location on Odessen and she could Fold Space as well (she will demonstrate this skill to The Alliance Commander depending upon dialogue options, leaving the player red faced). She was also able to slow down Tenebrae's effort of hollow her out - unprecedented demonstration of mental durability and willpower. She is LEGIT powerhouse from any perspective and can more than hold her own against any opponent by now.

How do you think she scales to Vaylin?

Malgus is 3rd or 4th strongest being, he dwarfs Satele who is around Darth Marr level which is like top 30-40

AUDITOR wrote:
How do you think she scales to Vaylin?

Vaylin's raw power and abilities were byproducts of Tenebrae's energies - truly unprecedented. She can take on any living being no doubt.

Satele Shan cannot be underestimated regardless - she have prodigious abilities in the ways of the Force and is never short on options and tricks - she is a survivor in short. No matter the odds, she is able to fight her way out. She flattened a location on Odessen - this is something you would expect from Master Yoda in telekinetics. She could also Fold Space before a Lightsaber could land on her and this application open numerous combat-applicable possibilities in theory. Things are no longer simple versus Satele. Anybody who makes a move on her in her prime years, learns something the hard way.

Probably Malgus.

Malgus ragdolls.

Malgus breaking through the (admittedly off-guard) Outlander's passive Force barriers, being vastly above Tau and Arn and scaling massively above any single protag as of Act 3 improves me more than Satele's feat.