AotC Obi-Wan Kenobi vs TPM Qui-Gon Jinn/Obi-Wan Kenobi

AotC Kenobi takes on the TPM duo.

Bonus round: AotC Obi-Wan's knowledge of his younger self and Jinn's fighting styles are removed.

Loses both rounds. Round 2 might be handily.

Probably AOTC Kenobi, not sure the duo can break his already elite Soresu, and he dwarfs them in applicable Force power. They’ll burn out faster than he will and then he can move in to strike

Qui Gon can possibly solo

This could go either way. 

Round 1: If the duo are fighting together on even ground I can see them eventually getting passed Kenobi's guard but I'm not sure if AOTC Kenobi would allow it to go that far.

Bonus Round: I'm not sure if this difference would matter since even if he didn't recognize the two, he'd still have knowledge of their Forms because he's trained in them so even if they visually looked different he'd still be able to develop counters for them.

TheNuisanceBird wrote:This could go either way. 

Round 1: If the duo are fighting together on even ground I can see them eventually getting passed Kenobi's guard but I'm not sure if AOTC Kenobi would allow it to go that far.

Bonus Round: I'm not sure if this difference would matter since even if he didn't recognize the two, he'd still have knowledge of their Forms because he's trained in them so even if they visually looked different he'd still be able to develop counters for them.

For round 2, the stipulations are that Kenobi's muscle memory knowledge and memories of his younger self and Jinn's skill set is removed, because they're not textbook Ataru duelists, their versions of Form IV are personalised to their own needs, especially Qui-Gon's.

@LOTL oi tell us what happens.

Team wins in round 1 and probably effortlessly in 2

Latham2000 wrote:

TheNuisanceBird wrote:This could go either way. 

Round 1: If the duo are fighting together on even ground I can see them eventually getting passed Kenobi's guard but I'm not sure if AOTC Kenobi would allow it to go that far.

Bonus Round: I'm not sure if this difference would matter since even if he didn't recognize the two, he'd still have knowledge of their Forms because he's trained in them so even if they visually looked different he'd still be able to develop counters for them.

For round 2, the stipulations are that Kenobi's muscle memory knowledge and memories of his younger self and Jinn's skill set is removed, because they're not textbook Ataru duelists, their versions of Form IV are personalised to their own needs, especially Qui-Gon's.

Lol I just now realized I read the bonus wrong. My bad.

TheNuisanceBird wrote:

Latham2000 wrote:

TheNuisanceBird wrote:This could go either way. 

Round 1: If the duo are fighting together on even ground I can see them eventually getting passed Kenobi's guard but I'm not sure if AOTC Kenobi would allow it to go that far.

Bonus Round: I'm not sure if this difference would matter since even if he didn't recognize the two, he'd still have knowledge of their Forms because he's trained in them so even if they visually looked different he'd still be able to develop counters for them.

For round 2, the stipulations are that Kenobi's muscle memory knowledge and memories of his younger self and Jinn's skill set is removed, because they're not textbook Ataru duelists, their versions of Form IV are personalised to their own needs, especially Qui-Gon's.

Lol I just now realized I read the bonus wrong. My bad.

yeah exactly don't be a pain in my ass based nuisance bird.

Ka-Caw motherfucker. 

Based what?

Jinn solos

TheNuisanceBird wrote:Ka-Caw motherfucker. 

Based what?

Based N U I S A N C E B I R D

Bump.

Changed my mind, AotC Kenobi takes them both.

Meatpants' massive character development

MEATPANTS

Duo. Don’t overate Soresu. Sheer volume, as we saw with Grievous and the three Magnaguards, can overload its defensive capacity. AotC Kenobi would be killed eventually, just as Shadow Conspiracy affirmed he would have with Darth Maul and Savage if Kenobi stayed in his defensive shell. TPM Kenobi alone is debatably just as capable if not more so offensively in case AotC Kenobi tries to switch it up. Two tier 7 fighters should be capable of overwhelming one tier 7 fighter most of the time.

Qui Gon solos