Reborn Darth Krayt vs Mace Windu

-Standard Rules

And as usual...

Spoiler:

Krayt beats any incarnation of Windu pre-ROTS.

TPM gives him a good fight, AOTC and TCW could conceivably take him. ROTS definitely takes him.

Prime Krayt is a combatant on the level of prime Luke and Sidious. He shreds.

And yet, he struggles with Cade Skywalker and Wyyrlok. GM Luke tier combatant my ass, the only thing that substantiates that notion is a fight against Abeloth, a fight so riddled with context it's difficult to assert parity between Krayt and Luke with a straight face. And guess what? Every other combative performance he has is the same. Total and complete dogshit.

I like how you act as if "struggling" (if you can even call it that) against Cade and Wyyrlok is something Luke wouldn't do. (See: Lumiya, Caedus, random Sith fodder, Gaalan, etc.)

The difference being that those fights have context and in universe explanations. Krayt just sucks.

Cute.

Concession accepted.

Krayt has never been GM Luke level.

Krayt was more than likely amped by the font of power in Apocalypse, as we know it can be drawn upon beyond shadows as well. He was never meant to be on par with Luke.

Krayt wins

Krayt being anywhere near GM Luke is complete and utter bullcrap.

I think Mace Windu is more than powerful enough that he could play a similar role to Krayt in Apocalypse.

Mace Windu with vaapad wins.

DC77 (Reborn) wrote:And yet, he struggles with Cade Skywalker and Wyyrlok.

Even if true, can you establish a cap for those two? On what basis are they "scrubs"?

IdrisianGraecus wrote:Krayt being anywhere near GM Luke is complete and utter bullcrap.

 
One of the few times you’re right wakanda

Mace obliterates

Wakanda? Really?

@MasterCilghal great sig btw mate

HellfireUnit wrote:@MasterCilghal great sig btw mate

Thank you. That statement from Cilghal was great, one of the main reasons I love FOTJ Outcast.

Krayt gets screwed over.

Either way. Though I am leaning towards Windu.

Krayt

Anyone care to share why they think Krayt or Mace wins?

Blade_of_Dorin wrote:Anyone care to share why they think Krayt or Mace wins?

See my respective debates with HP and db77