Lumiya vs Galen Marek

Galen Marek in his prime vs Lumiya in her prime

My knowledge on Galen is extremely limited, but Lumiya stands no chance here. She’s far too inconsistent (and her best showings have circumstances) to beat someone like Galen.

Galen stomps lmao.

Galen should overwhelm.

Lumiya's unique lightwhip gives her a sizable advantage over Galen Marek in physical combat, as it's specifically designed to get around a Jedi who wields a single lightsaber. To my knowledge, Galen has never encountered anything even remotely analogous to her weapon. If she can stay in close, she might have a chance at beating him with it, considering she tooled post-RotJ Luke with it fairly easily in their first encounter, far before her own prime. 

That said, the moment Galen has a chance to bring Force powers into this, she loses. She has a couple tricky Force abilities, but she's a pretty inferior Force user, to my recollection, and I don't believe she has any answer to Force lightning. The best she's been shown capable of has been illusions and Force phantoms. Even then, she typically needed a nexus for her more impressive showings. Galen takes this by virtue of actually being a combative Force user.

Galen TK's her out of the sky

Underachiever599 wrote:Lumiya's unique lightwhip gives her a sizable advantage over Galen Marek in physical combat, as it's specifically designed to get around a Jedi who wields a single lightsaber. To my knowledge, Galen has never encountered anything even remotely analogous to her weapon. If she can stay in close, she might have a chance at beating him with it, considering she tooled post-RotJ Luke with it fairly easily in their first encounter, far before her own prime. 

That said, the moment Galen has a chance to bring Force powers into this, she loses. She has a couple tricky Force abilities, but she's a pretty inferior Force user, to my recollection, and I don't believe she has any answer to Force lightning. The best she's been shown capable of has been illusions and Force phantoms. Even then, she typically needed a nexus for her more impressive showings. Galen takes this by virtue of actually being a combative Force user.

Jeensarai1 wants to know your location 

i’m  joking of course, it’s simply that this logic similar to that of Jeensarai or the other Youtube debaters is very uncommon here, although I don’t consider it inferior nor wrong.

Galen force pushes her and she shatters into a billion pieces.

Galen, obviously

MasterCilghal wrote:

Underachiever599 wrote:Lumiya's unique lightwhip gives her a sizable advantage over Galen Marek in physical combat, as it's specifically designed to get around a Jedi who wields a single lightsaber. To my knowledge, Galen has never encountered anything even remotely analogous to her weapon. If she can stay in close, she might have a chance at beating him with it, considering she tooled post-RotJ Luke with it fairly easily in their first encounter, far before her own prime. 

That said, the moment Galen has a chance to bring Force powers into this, she loses. She has a couple tricky Force abilities, but she's a pretty inferior Force user, to my recollection, and I don't believe she has any answer to Force lightning. The best she's been shown capable of has been illusions and Force phantoms. Even then, she typically needed a nexus for her more impressive showings. Galen takes this by virtue of actually being a combative Force user.

Jeensarai1 wants to know your location 

i’m  joking of course, it’s simply that this logic similar to that of Jeensarai or the other Youtube debaters is very uncommon here, although I don’t consider it inferior nor wrong.

The difference is, Jensaarai would just say something and not even attempt to give an example or any kind of evidence.

Plot twist: He is is Jeensarai1 lmao

Galen rips her to shreds