Anakin and Obi-Wan vs Revan and Malak

- Kenobi as of his fight with MFV on Mustafar; Anakin right before he turns to the dark side
- Revan and Malak are both at their respective peaks
- Fight takes place on Mustafar
- Rest of the rules are standard

Which duo takes the cake?

Skyguy and sarcasm king takes this.

Edit: Since the question has changed this answer is no longer valid

This is a close matchup. KF Vader is the most powerful member here but he also has the weakest member as a teammate in Kenobi. However I could see Kenobi holding off Malak long enough for Anakin to deal with Revan and then Malak gets stomped by himself.

Revan & Malak in a great fight.

KingofBlades wrote:This is a close matchup. KF Vader is the most powerful member here but he also has the weakest member as a teammate in Kenobi. However I could see Kenobi holding off Malak long enough for Anakin to deal with Revan and then Malak gets stomped by himself.

It's just Lightside Anakin, not KFV. I'll alter the description to make it more clear

Team 2

Reasons, anyone?

I view Obi Wan in between Malak and Revan as of the game. He should be able to beat Malak

Anakin vs Revan is interesting. Not sure who wins especially as this is tier 8 Anakin

Ah in that case team 2 takes it. SoR Revan is marginally more powerful than LS Anakin and SF Malak is likewise a bit more powerful than than Kenobi

I hold lightside Anakin (assuming this is Anakin without the 'furnace heart'), Obi Wan, and Malak all roughly in the same tier while I think prime Revan is a notch above everyone else in this fight.

Prime Revan solos, to be honest.

LadyKulvax wrote:Prime Revan solos, to be honest.

You think the gap between LS Anakin and KF Vader is that drastic?

Absolutely.

Tbh KF Anakin is too damn overrated. It is only an Anakin not holding back. If KF could defeat Revan, LS Anakin can as well.

He literally goes from tier 8 to tier 9, which is stated to be like the Richter scale in difference. How is ROTS Anakin anywhere near KF!Vader?

HellfireUnit wrote:Tbh KF Anakin is too damn overrated. It is only an Anakin not holding back. If KF could defeat Revan, LS Anakin can as well.

Now that I think about it LS Anakin went from having a solid edge on Dooku to effortlessly stomping him as "Zonakin". Since KF Vader is above even zonakin the gap is pretty massive

Considering KF Anakin struggled in the Jedi Temple and lost against Kenobi, I don't see any difference. And KF still sucks at using the Force. Dark Side also made him unstable so I don't see KF performing well against high tier characters any different than LS Anakin, maybe even worse.

It's never said anywhere that he struggled in the Temple. Nor is using Mustafar Vader's performance against the absolute best counter for him possible, a downer against KF.

KingofBlades wrote:

HellfireUnit wrote:Tbh KF Anakin is too damn overrated. It is only an Anakin not holding back. If KF could defeat Revan, LS Anakin can as well.

Now that I think about it LS Anakin went from having a solid edge on Dooku to effortlessly stomping him as "Zonakin". Since KF Vader is above even zonakin the gap is pretty massive

Hım beating Dooku isn't that simple. There are various reasons Dooku lost as you know. LS Anakin tapped into Dark Side but had a clear mind at least. KF Anakin doesn't have that.

team one wins if they can close the distance fast enough because they are superior in sabers .
if not kenobi gets ragdolled and LS anakin overwhelmed .

IH rage amped anakin/KF vader may very well solo , obi wan would be a drag for him here .

Revan and Malak win - Revan being in his prime incarnation is just too much. If it was KOTOR Revan, then the PT team would win imo.

Meatpants wrote:Revan and Malak win - Revan being in his prime incarnation is just too much. If it was KOTOR Revan, then the PT team would win imo.

This ^

Anakin should beat either. Kenobi beats Malak and can fight Revan quite capably.

Team 1

Greysentinel365 wrote:Anakin should beat either. Kenobi beats Malak and can fight Revan quite capably.

Team 1

Normally I'd agree with this statement but SF Malak and SoR Revan fighting against base versions of these characters makes it a defeat for the Jedi team imo.

Team 2 wins.