Three Vitiates vs Three Sith Lords

Vitiate from the Novel, SWTOR Vitiate at the end of Jedi Knight Storyline Act II, SWTOR Vitiate at the end of JK Act III.

vs.

Darth Caedus, Darth Krayt and Exar Kun


Fight takes place in Dark Temple throne room.

Who wins?

The other Sith have clear advantages. Not only do they boast the most powerful guy here in Darth Krayt, but the Vitiate's also have the weakest person in Act III Vitiate. Even if the other two Vitiate's could compensate in power somehow, they are woefully outclassed in skill and tactical acumen by all three of their adversaries. Then there's fact that Novel Vitiate is pretty much an unknown when he doesn't benefit from his amp (everyone here will be amped equally by the nexus), so you can't really say with any degree of certainty that he'd be able to take out Kun or Caedus. All we know is that he caps around Novel Revan's level.

With all that, I'd hand the other Sith the victory by a fairly comfortable margin.

Make it Valk, and he pretty much carries, but these versions of Vitiate suck.

Krayt carries

Novel Vitiate beats Caedus and SWTOR Vitiate beats Krayt. The only member of the Sith team who wins his matchup is Kun but he's woefully outclassed by either version of Vitiate so it's irrelevant.

The Vitiate's. I'd peg Jacen and Krayt around KOTOR Revan, substantially beneath Vitiate either as of the novel or SWTOR. Kun and weakened Act 3 Vitiate are just kinda useless.