Maul, Vader and Kenobi V Arcann and Revan

Maul as of Shadow Conspiracy.

Vader as of Return Of The Jedi.

Kenobi as of Revenge Of the Sith.

Arcann as of Knights Of The Eternal Throne.

Revan as of The Novel.

Who Wins?

Team 2

Team 2. Solid fight though.

Under my new methodology, it's plausible team one wins if Arcann or Revan don't pick off someone quickly (especially if it's novel Revan).

Also, is Obi-Wan in the mindset he was against Anakin or against Dooku? I think there's a distinction there.

@DarthAnt66 Anakin.

Under my old methodology, team one stomps

Team two murks.

Team 1

DarthAnt66 wrote:Under my new methodology, it's plausible team one wins if Arcann or Revan don't pick off someone quickly (especially if it's novel Revan).

Also, is Obi-Wan in the mindset he was against Anakin or against Dooku? I think there's a distinction there.

I don't see either of them picking off any of team 1 quickly

Team 1 yeah

Nope, Arcann is far and away the MVP. Everyone else is below Revan.

Split or team 2 tbh.

DarthAnt66 wrote:Under my new methodology, it's plausible team one wins if Arcann or Revan don't pick off someone quickly (especially if it's novel Revan).

Also, is Obi-Wan in the mindset he was against Anakin or against Dooku? I think there's a distinction there.

Yeah, I'd like to hear the rationale for either Revan or Arcann picking off anybody in team 1 quickly

Revan > Surik > Trayus!Surik > Trayus!Traya > Dantooine!Traya >> Zez-Kai Ell, Lonna Vash, Vrook Lamar, Kavar > DS!Atris > Vrook Lamar ~ Lonna Vash ~ Kavar ~ Zez-Kai Ell > Star Forge Bastila

Is an insane line of scaling for Revan, tbh.

Lol

Lmao.

1

This basically comes down to whether you think two windu tiers can beat three kenobi tiers. I'm inclined to believe so

Windu tier my ass

Kenobi tier my ass

Kenobi>Arcann>Revan>Vader>>Maul

Revan Reborn was >/= Novel Vitiate. He was drastically more powerful than Nyriss who showed parity with the exile. The same exile who bested Traya on a dark side nexus. Traya lol stomped 3 jedi masters simultaneously. A weaker incarnation of Revan defeated SF Malak, a being more powerful than Exar Kun, despite being hindered by an incredibly powerful nexus in the starforge while Malak's energy was being repeatedly restored by the jedi he captured. Him being Windu tier is right where he belongs. Early KotFE Arcann basically stomped SoR HOT. Accounting for the growth he experiences by the end of KotET he should be Windu Tier. Notice I say tier as I still think Windu would beat Arcann in a fight. As for your placing of Kenobi, Vader and Maul relative to each other I more or less agree

Valkorion is the only person from TOR who’s Windu/Yoda tier

CuckedCurry

in fact it’s even debatable if Valkorion’s Yoda/Windu tier in terms of combative skill and power

Valk’s Yaddle tier