Bastila Shan vs Lord Scourge (Novel)

All-out

Ehhh, Scourge.

Eh, can go either way.

I will say Bastilla. Scourge is amped by the Dromund Kaas nexus for most of the time during the novel, the nexus was so strong that much later it still nearly seduced Kyle Katarn to the darkside. Bastila could somewhat tussle with Malak, while Exile and Scourge were kinda getting stomped by Nyriss. Malak losing to massively disadvantaged Redeemed Revan is a serious mark against him, but Revan also cucked him by stealing Bastila back from him pre-fight, destroying his mental before they even crossed blades and if his last moments are any indication he was conflicted.