Suited Vader vs Kit Fisto Sabers only?

ANH Vader loses in dueling only. ESB/RotJ Vader because he isn't a half man, half machine.

Fisto

Latham2000 wrote:ANH Vader loses in dueling only. ESB/RotJ Vader because he isn't a half man, half machine.

Are you sure now is the time for humour, my Lord?

ILS wrote:

Latham2000 wrote:ANH Vader loses in dueling only. ESB/RotJ Vader because he isn't a half man, half machine.

Are you sure now is the time for humour, my Lord?

Lucas's remarks in TPM featurette suggest that ANH Vader, the "half man, half machine,"is less skilled than a Jedi in his prime fighting in the prime of the Jedi, and Kit Fisto as far as we know, is probably in his prime during RotS, so he would fall under that category. Moreover, Fisto's fighting style is extremely unorthodox, and we don't know how many sparring matches he had with Fisto back in the day, so Fisto could come out victorious.

Too bad the "half-man, half-machine" status doesn't extend to ESB/RotJ Vader, and that version of Vader fists Fisto.

I, too, will be in desperate need of life support, for I feel my lungs may collapse from the sheer hilarity of what I am hearing. Good show, DarthLatham, good show indeed.

Though Vader is stronger, more experienced, more durable and more hell bent on surviving, and he will be furious at the mere sight of this scumbag Jedi being alive again, I hereby retconn my previous statements and award Lord Vader the victory.

Let it go down in the annals of history as yet another victory for our glorious regime. So it is written.

Kit could win.

Even ANH Vader wins for various reasons. ESB doesn't ragdoll, but keeps force pushing Fisto until he stops moving

> Korriban wrote:Even ANH Vader wins for various reasons. ESB doesn't ragdoll, but keeps force pushing Fisto until he stops moving

Isn't this a sabers only match up?

That being said, I'd argue Vader by TFU could probably easily take it, going by the way his level of lightsaber skill is described by Galen Marek. Anything past TFU is just too far beyond Kit Fisto.

Ultimately, I think this contest boils down to morality. I have felt nothing but apathy and disappointment for Kit Fisto, but but felt respect and admiration for Darth Vader, so the idea of Vader winning would be completely morally sound.

if its only sabers then: 
ANH version wins with little difficulty
 ESB/ROTJ slaps the smiley dude