Kit Fisto vs Ki-Adi Mundi

Standard rules.

Mundi

Mundi.

Mundi.

Mundi one-shots.

Mundi

My faith in this forum is restored.

Not sure Tbh. While I don’t really scale Fisto off lasting 8 seconds against Sidious as Sidious could have blitzed him if he targeted him first, I still feel he has the better feats then mundi not really sure tho.

Could go either way, though I'd tend to favor Mundi. They're both above Koon though.

Mundi has better feats, ngl.

Both are kind of sketchy. Fisto did better against Grievous and Ki Adi did better against Ventress.

TCW Grievous is inconsistent(one episode he's winning against Kenobi another he's losing to a regular council member) and for all intents and purposes is a completely different character and fighter than his EU counterpart not to mention Ki Adi was by his own admission exhausted when he fought Grievous.

When Ventress fought with Ki Adi she had negative circumstances with her being in hostile territory surrounded by clones, but Ki Adi did prove he wasn't a pushover and she choose to withdraw rather than fight to the finish.

Ventresss vs Fisto was circumstantial. It's specifically stated in the novel that she took advantage in analyzing Fisto and Kenobi's styles just before clashed. In the hyper precise world of lightsaber dueling every advantage counts. She may well be better anyways but this doesn't prove Fisto is in her stomping range(not that it was a stomp).

Honestly I don't know.

Yeah, Fisto beating a fucked up Grievous is a really great comparison between him and Fisto.

DC77 wrote:Yeah, Fisto beating a fucked up Grievous is a really great comparison between him and Fisto.

Wollf's blog has issues with it.

Yeah Grievous was injured. So what? He was still losing. And he has a poor track record against council members outside of jobber Kenobi anyways.

\"Wollfmyth wrote:Now onto the fight itself: as is made evident from the video, Grievous seems to be driving Fisto back, forcing him to use the environment. This is confirmed by StarWars.com saying Grievous overwhelmed Kit Fisto:While Gor was destroyed, Grievous himself killed a young Padawan called Nahdar and overwhelmed Kit Fisto in lightsaber combat. The General survived to fight another day."] StarWars.com: General Grievous

Yeah he overwhelmed Fisto when the magnaguards showed up as back up. Otherwise what sense does this quote make "how quickly does power change hands". Fisto was winning against Grievous deal with it.

Wollfmyth wrote:What we see here is that a fully-repaired Grievous, despite an environmental disadvantage holds an advantage over both Kit Fisto and Nahdar Vebb

That doesn't happen. Against both as well as the squad of clone troopers he gets his legs sawed off and is forced to retreat. Grievous never held the advantage against both. Grievous losing to Fisto isn't an outlier.

Grievous had a strength advantage that's all. Skill wise he's a mediocre duelist as per Filini himself: "You can just sit and watch that scene and watch in the background while Ventress tries to get away all of these zombies attacking Grievous. And he actually comes out on kind of the upside of it, which is good. A lot of people liked that, that he wasn't easily trumped. I still don't believe that, at this point -- one-to-one -- that Grievous could really take out someone like Ventress in a lightsaber fight." - "Something you said on the Rebels Recon, you called Inquisitor's lightsaber is ''cheat'' … Dave Filoni : ''I always thought Grievous that way right, he can use a lightsaber but you know to kill Nahdar he plug a gun and shoot Nahdar. He doesn't care."

Next up: Kit Fisto disarming Grievous. Let's take a bit to discuss why this isn't that impressive... Grievous, in-canon, doesn't seem to be as technically skilled as his EU counterpart, and Filoni seems to have him written as an expert killer solely for his unorthodox. With that, it's been fairly easy to work past a few swinging propeller strikes and disarm the General. wrote:

Ding ding. Grieovus isn't that skilled. He pales comparison to his EU counterpart. Fisto or any council member getting the better of him isn't an outlier.

I made a full response in the blog itself and still stand by it except I do concede he was injured to an unknown extent. Not that it matters given TCW Grievous poor track record against council members and Filini's low opinion of his skills.

And I never denied any of that (Grievous losing and not overwhelming the duo at peak as well as getting beat by Fisto)...

You however are trying to build a comparison that's faulty given the unknown nature of Grievous's injuries. Fisto winning the fight is irrelevant unless you can somehow demonstrate the General's injuries weren't significant and that Mundi's exhaustion wasn't significant. The Ventress comparison is far more reliable.

DC77 wrote:

Sorry didn't read your post properly.

Still that's kind of my point. Fisto's performance against a completely different version of the Greivous Ki-Adi fought while exhausted isn't quantifiable.

But at the same time you can't deny there were negative circumstances at work against Fisto vs Ventress. Ventress had analyzed his style before hand which is a big advantage over Fisto who doesn't know her style and Ventress was in hostile territory with clone troopers everywhere when she clashed with Ki Adi, it wasn't in her best interest to get into a prolonged duel.

She killed the clones though. It was just her and Mundi, and she still ran.

She "ran" because the ship was crashing.

Even without the Asajj fight, Mundi still wins imo.

Kit smashes. Mundi is a nooblord.

Fisto wins.

Fisto. Mundi has nothing

Fisto has nothing, oh except “Muh reacting to Sidious” with Windu for 5 seconds.

Better than the rest of the B-Team, lmao.

Mundi impresses me more than B team.